The Problem With Fixing Adtech


Adtech has spent the last 20 years trying to fix itself.
Every few years, a new challenge emerges and, almost inevitably, we build another technology to solve it. A new layer. Another shiny new toy.
The intention is usually good, and the technology is often clever. But somewhere along the way, we've created a system that can be incredibly sophisticated and mind-numbingly complex at the same time.
Ask a simple question like “Did my media work?” and the answer can feel like an essay full of “yeah, but no, but yeah…” as Vicky Pollard from Little Britain would put it.
The irony is that an industry obsessed with making media buying more efficient has somehow made the process feel more complicated. Maybe the problem isn't that we haven't built enough technology, but that we've been trying to fix the wrong thing.
The stack became the solution to the stack
Programmatic wasn't designed as one connected system. It evolved.
DSPs solved one problem. SSPs another. Verification companies fixed one thing. Data providers fixed antoher. Each solved something useful. Layer by layer, the ecosystem became more capable. But more complex at the same time.
I remember joining PubMatic back in 2011 and seeing the LumaScape for Display Advertising. It felt like a 'Where's Wally' even back then. Now? I think Wally is long gone.
We've created a web of complexity designed to solve complexity. And that leaves us with an uncomfortable question: How many layers does it take before the solution becomes part of the problem?
We're seeing the consequences
You don't have to look far to see the tension.
Google's ad tech business is currently at the centre of a major antitrust case in the US, with regulators examining the structure and conduct of a market built around interconnected advertising technologies.
Whatever the eventual outcome, the broader story is revealing. An industry built by connecting more and more pieces together is now having to question whether those pieces still work in the way buyers, sellers and publishers need them to.
And it's not just traditional adtech. We're seeing a new wave of products promising to make media buying simpler through AI, automation and new approaches to media packaging.
The thing is, the technology isn't the problem. It's how we use it. Is it fit for the challenges we see today? Does it genuinely change how the system works, or simply putting a smarter interface on top of the old one?
Because adding a smarter layer to a fragmented system doesn't make it connected.
It just makes the fragmented system smarter at being fragmented.
Start at the end
So perhaps it's time to stop adding and start again.
And the easiest place to start? The outcome.
The question every campaign should start with: What are we actually trying to achieve? Once you know that, the rest of the decisions should follow.
What needs to happen to achieve it?
What decisions need to be made?
What information do we need?
How should those decisions connect?
How do we know whether they worked?
The outcome should connect the brief to the plan, the plan to the media, the media to activation, and activation to measurement. Then, when the loop closes, what we've learned should influence the next decision.
Simple.
(Or at least, it should be).
We had the advantage of starting later
This is why being a newer business has its advantages.
We didn't have to retrofit a system built 20 years ago, we could look at what the industry had built, understand why those pieces existed, and ask a different question: If we were starting again, would we build it this way?
Our answer was no.
Not because the technology that came before was bad. Much of it was brilliant.
But the problems advertisers are trying to solve today aren't necessarily the problems the industry was originally built around.
You don't need to understand how the electricity grid works to turn on a light. You don't need to understand every component of your phone to send a message. So why should advertisers need to navigate a maze of disconnected systems to understand whether their media delivered the outcome they asked for?
The complexity should sit behind the experience, not in front of it.
The future of media shouldn't be about navigating the machinery. It should be about seeing the outcome.



Comments